Study: Educational Toys Often Don't Educate

Majority of educational video games have little information to back their claims

ByABC News
February 18, 2009, 11:17 PM

LAS VEGAS, Jan. 9, 2008 — -- Despite claims that they help kids learn, the majority of educational video games have little if any research to back up their claims, says a study released at the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas.

According to "D Is for Digital," a study released by the newly created Joan Ganz Cooney Center at Sesame Workshop, only two of 69 "educational" video games studied were based on educational curriculum, said Terry Fitzpatrick, executive vice president of distribution at Sesame Workshop.

"These games claim educational value but with no research to support these assertions," Fitzpatrick said. "With cell phones, iPods and portable DVD players our children are engaging with media more than ever. Now is a good time to step back and take a look at where we're going."

The center studied more than 300 digital educational products aimed at children ages 3 to 11. According to the study, few of the products used children's education research in their development. In 2006, the Top 20 video games for kids earned more than $500 million.

"The use of consumer electronics is quite widespread among kids starting between the ages of 4 and 5, which is the average age that kids start using a computer," said Anita Frazier, a research analyst at NPD Group. "Over the last three years of our studies, we've found that not only has the use of these devices computers, cell phones, personal digital music players, gaming devices increased, but the average age that kids use them has decreased slightly over time, meaning that kids are using them at younger ages.

"Kids are true digital natives and use these devices very naturally, whereas a lot of adults look at kids in amazement as they seamlessly navigate between the physical and digital worlds," said Frazier. "It's quite natural and no big deal for the kids."

"Technology is a mainstay in kid's lives. Clearly, entertainment doesn't have to be mindless," Fitzpatrick said. "Whether they build castles or avatars, kids will always be kids."